Residual Carrier Risk (Negative Screen)
Post-test carrier probability after a negative screening result using Bayes theorem
Calculator
Why use it
Critical for post-test counseling in expanded carrier screening (ECS). Avoids the clinical error of treating a negative screen as a complete exclusion. Quantifies the safety margin provided by the test and allows couples to make truly informed reproductive decisions.
About
When an individual tests negative on a carrier screening panel, their risk of being a carrier is dramatically reduced — but never reaches zero. This is because no panel has 100% detection rate (sensitivity). Mutations missed by the assay remain undetected. Using Bayes theorem, this calculator computes the precise "residual carrier risk" after a negative result, and propagates that risk to estimate the probability of having an affected child based on the partner's carrier status.
When to use
- Post-test counseling after a negative expanded carrier screening result
- When one partner is a known carrier and the other has a negative panel result
- Comparing detection rates between targeted genotyping panels vs. sequencing approaches
- Explaining why a negative result is reassuring but not a guarantee
Formula
Pearls & pitfalls
- Residual Risk = [Prior × (1 − DR)] / [Prior × (1 − DR) + (1 − Prior) × 1]
- The higher the Detection Rate (sequencing > genotyping), the lower the residual risk.
- For CF genotyping panels (90% DR) in Caucasians (prior 1/25): residual risk ≈ 1 in 241.
- For CF sequencing (>99% DR) in the same population: residual risk drops to ≈ 1 in 2,500+.
- Always use ethnicity-specific detection rates — panels are calibrated to common mutations in specific ancestries.
- A negative result in a low-prior-risk population provides greater reassurance than in a high-prior-risk population.
Next steps
Communicate the residual risk clearly. If the residual carrier risk is unacceptably high for the couple (especially when the other partner is a known carrier), discuss: (1) next-generation sequencing of the gene if only genotyping was performed; (2) PGT-M (Preimplantation Genetic Testing for Monogenic Disorders); (3) Prenatal diagnosis (CVS or amniocentesis).
Evidence
Standard Bayesian calculation universally taught in genetic counseling and clinical genetics training programs. Endorsed by ACMG, SMFM, and ACOG for post-carrier-screening counseling. Applied in all major clinical genetics textbooks (Thompson & Thompson, Nussbaum et al.).
References
- ACOG Committee Opinion 690: Carrier Screening in the Age of Genomic Medicine. Obstet Gynecol. 2017;129(3):e35-e40. — link
- Gregg AR et al. Expanding carrier screening: ACMG practice resource. Genet Med. 2021;23(10):1793-1806. — link
- Beaudet AL, Belmont JW. Array-Based DNA Diagnostics: Let the Revolution Begin. Annu Rev Med. 2008;59:113-129. — link